The European Union Affairs Committee of the Riigikogu (Parliament of Estonia) initiated and submitted to the Riigikogu for parliamentary proceedings a draft Resolution stating that the European Commission’s proposal for a Regulation on affordable housing would unduly restrict Member States’ ability to regulate their own housing markets and was not in line with the principle of subsidiarity.
Chair of the European Union Affairs Committee Kadri Tali pointed out when presenting the draft Resolution that improving the affordability of housing was an important objective, but the measures chosen to achieve this must take into account the different needs and possibilities of Member States. “We do not question the aim of making housing more affordable for people. The question is who will be able to resolve these issues in the best way. Tallinn, Tartu and smaller Estonian municipalities have different needs, not to mention those of European countries as a whole. The European Union’s common objectives are important, but they must not unreasonably restrict the right of Member States to decide for themselves,” Tali said.
According to Tali, the European Commission has not sufficiently justified why new mandatory rules at European Union level are needed for this purpose, and what they would add to the existing legal framework. “The European Union must help to resolve common problems, but decisions must be made at the level where they can be resolved in the best way. That is the essence of the principle of proximity. We do not have to choose between European cooperation and Estonia’s interests – our task is to stand for both,” Tali emphasised.
Such objections have also been presented in other Member States. The Government of Finland has criticised the proposal on the grounds of proportionality and restricting the competence of Member States. Both houses of the Parliament of Italy have submitted a reasoned opinion on the proposal, and the Senate of Poland has also supported the view that the proposed regulation does not comply with the principle of subsidiarity.
At the request of the European Union Affairs Committee of the Riigikogu, the Legal and Research Department of the Chancellery of the Riigikogu analysed the proposed regulation’s compliance with the principle of subsidiarity and found that the proposal did not comply with this principle. According to the analysis, the proposed regulation seeks to bring the regulation of the conditions of housing policy interventions increasingly to the European Union level, although the housing markets of the Member States differ significantly. The introduction of uniform requirements would restrict Member States’ discretion without sufficient justification for the need for action at European Union level and its added value.
The European Union Affairs Committee made a proposal to the Board of the Riigikogu to set 12 November at 4 p.m. as the deadline for submission of motions to amend to the draft Resolution of the Riigikogu “Reasoned Opinion to the President of the European Parliament, the President of the European Commission and the Presidency of the Council of the European Union on the Incompatibility with the Principle of Subsidiarity of the Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a framework for measures in Member States to safeguard housing affordability and availability (Affordable Housing Act)”, and to include the draft Resolution on the agenda for the plenary sitting on 17 November and hold the final vote.